Reviewed by Jo-Anne Bishop
(Pictured: Cast of Prescription: Murder, Tameka Brown, Eve Cohen, Andre Cormier, David Pasquino, Sam Didi, and Makayla Ashenden. Photo Credit: Ross Davidson.)
Murder is rarely this polished – or this fun to watch.
On the Auburn Stage at the Grand Theatre in London, Ontario, Prescription: Murder wastes no time pulling its audience into a sleek, slow-burning game of cat and mouse. Running March 19–29 and directed by Stephen Mitchell, this black box production leans into intimacy and largely thrives because of it.
Originally written by William Link and Richard Levinson, the play serves as the foundation for the iconic television detective Columbo. The story centres on a brilliant and calculating psychiatrist who believes he has devised the perfect crime, only to find himself gradually entangled in a battle of wits with the seemingly unassuming Lieutenant Columbo. What unfolds is less a traditional whodunit and more a tense psychological chess match, where the outcome feels inevitable, but the journey is where all the intrigue lies.
(Pictured: David Pasquino as Lieutenant Columbo. Photo Credit: Ross Davdson.)
The ensemble is tight and reliable across the board. Makayla Ashenden brings a grounded vulnerability to Susan Hudson, while Tameka Brown and Eve Cohen offer strong, steady support as Miss Petrie and Claire Flemming. Sam Didi moves seamlessly through dual roles, and David Pasquino’s Lieutenant Columbo is understated, patient, and quietly probing—exactly what the role demands.
But let’s be honest: this is André Cormier’s show.
(Pictured: Andre Cormier as Dr. Roy Flemming. Photo Credit: Ross Davidson.)
As Dr. Roy Flemming, Cormier delivers a performance that is sharp, controlled, and magnetic. He walks a perfect line between charm and menace, with only the slightest of line slips in an otherwise near-flawless turn. What stands out most is his precision. Every look and every pause feels intentional. His seething, barely contained irritation with Columbo simmers just beneath the surface, and it’s riveting to watch. You don’t just see the character unravel; you feel it.
The staging makes smart use of the black box space, carving out distinct environments—the doctor’s office, reception area, apartment, and Columbo’s workspace—without overcomplicating things. A few of the scene changes occasionally drag a beat too long, but they’re supported by effective lighting and sound that keep the tension alive.
(Pictured: Tameka Brown as Miss Petrie, Andre Cormier as Dr. Roy Flemming, and Eve Cohen as Claire Flemming. Photo Credit: Ross Davdson.)
Costuming and attention to detail further ground the production in authenticity. Each character is clearly defined through wardrobe, but it’s Lieutenant Columbo who benefits most from these thoughtful choices. David Pasquino appears perfectly dishevelled with mussed hair, a slightly rumpled coat, and even an untied shoe that subtly reinforces the character’s offbeat, absent-minded persona. It’s a small but effective touch, and one that adds texture and believability without feeling trite or overstated.
(Pictured: Andre Cormier as Dr. Roy Flemming and David Pasquino as Lt. Columbo. Photo Credit: Ross Davdson.)
There are a few minor cracks in the illusion. Some set pieces wobble when doors are slammed, which briefly pulls focus. But these moments are small and quickly forgotten. Overall, this Prescription: Murder is lean, engaging, and anchored by a standout central performance. It’s a confident piece of theatre that knows exactly what it’s doing—and for fans of classic detective drama, it absolutely delivers.
IF YOU GO:
What: DJP Productions presents Prescription: Murder by William Link and Richard Levinson
When: March 19-29, 2026
Where: Auburn Stage, Grand Theatre, 471 Richmond St, London Ontario.
Tickets: $31.70-$36.70 Prescription: Murder | The Grand Theatre
Reviewed by Jo-Anne Bishop.
Background and Experience in the Arts
My background in the Arts started with an early love for music and dance. I attended my first concert at 10 years old (Helix at the Sarnia Arena in 1983!) and began tap and modern jazz dance lessons around the same time. My love for live theatre was built through school trips to the Stratford Festival to see plays like Romeo and Juliet, The Merchant of Venice, and Macbeth, and a trip to Toronto for The Phantom of the Opera, which quickly became my all-time favourite.
I dreamed of performing for many years, but being too self-conscious to audition in high school, I sat on the sidelines and instead reviewed music and theatre for our school newspaper. In 2013, I finally pushed my fears aside and was cast in my first play, Laughter on the 23rd Floor, as Carol Wyman, the only female writer on the Max Prince show. I have since performed in productions of Birth (Jillian, 2016), Hamish (Annette, 2023) and The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime (Mrs. Alexander, 2024).
Previous Reviewing Activities
SCITS, Sarnia, Ontario – High school newspaper reviewer for Music and the Arts
London Fringe Festival, London, Ontario, 2012-2015
Independent Reviewer and Blogger (Theatre in London and The Pollyanna Papers), 2015-2016?
Why am I jumping back into the fray now?
After performing for a few years, I’ve decided to take a break from the grind of auditioning, rehearsing and performing. While I love it immensely, it’s a lot of work. Performing has given me a whole new perspective and appreciation of what goes into a production and the ability to look at reviewing with a fresh set of eyes.
Thoughts about the London arts and culture scene, especially local theatre
Hoo wee! London has such a wealth of talent, from youth to adults. Every time I see a play, I am amazed at how talented our actors, directors, producers, set/prop/costume/light/sound designers are. I don’t think causal observers realize just how much goes into making a production from the audition to the curtain call. It is a huge undertaking, and to think our theatres produce such world-class productions on some very tight budgets is astounding, especially at the community theatre level, where volunteers do everything.
Sadly, since COVID, I have witnessed a huge decline in attendance at performances, and it breaks my heart. I have also noticed a sad lack of reviews lately, which I find are necessary to give people an idea of what to expect and a reason to go to the theatre.
So, before I can put my feet on the stage again, I want to help put bodies in the seats. We need to reignite a love for theatre and the arts in this city.
Richard's Blog 