Reviewed by Richard Young
(Pictured: Members of the Guys and Dolls company. Photo: David Hou.)
Full Disclosure: I’ve always been a sucker for full-scale Broadway musicals. And, before the “Drama Police” show up in my Facebook Comments, I appreciate drama and “serious issues plays” just as much as the next guy. But there’s something about musicals that attracts me to them every time.
From the opening chords of its first production number to the final bows of its outstanding Cast, the Tony Award-winning production of Guys and Dolls, now playing in previews at the Stratford Festival, is a spectacle that theatre-goers do not want to miss, if for no other reason than to allow them to escape the harrowing front-page news of 2026.
Let’s start with the stellar veteran Cast.
I would gladly pay to hear Stratford veteran actor Dan Chameroy read a phone book. His portrayal of Sky Masterson, a notoriously lucky gambler willing to bet on just about anything, is brilliant. Add to that Olivia Sinclair-Brisbane, the focus of his unrequited love, as the pious and beautiful Sergeant Sarah Brown of the Save-a-Soul Mission, and you have a winning combination.
The play’s other love story between small-time gambler Nathan Detroit, played masterfully by Mark Urhe, who runs a floating craps game in need of a location, and his long-suffering fiancée of fourteen years, Miss Adelaide, played by Jennifer Ryder-Shaw, is equally appealing.
(Pictured: Olivia Sinclair-Brisbane and Jennifer Ryder-Shaw. Photo: Dan Hou.)
The supporting cast of stereotypical small-time grifters adds an extra dimension to the story and further encourages the audience to suspend their disbelief. Characters with names like Nicely-Nicely Johnson (Steve Ross), Benny Southstreet (Gabriel Antonacci), Rusty Charlie (Devon Michael-Brown), Harry the Horse (Henry Firmston) and Big Julie (Juan Chioran) come and go on the stage with great aplomb.
(Pictured: Members of the company. Photo: David Hou.)
The ensemble actors shine in the show’s outstanding production numbers, choreographed by Stratford veteran, director Donna Feore. Stunning dance moves, accentuated by impossible gymnastic feats, leave the audience gasping for air.
The play’s costumes and sets are a joy to behold, as is expected of Stratford Festival productions. The men are dressed in garish vintage 1940s pinstripe suits, while the women look like they walked off the screen of a classic Hollywood film noir.
Sets range from a dingy New York City streetscape, a Havana nightclub, a lively cabaret, a mission, and a NYC sewer! Set changes are done quickly and seamlessly.
(Pictured: Members of the company. Photo: David Hou.)
And the music!
Under the baton of Music Director, Franklin Brasz, the cast and pit orchestra perform songs that have become part of the Great American Songbook, including If I Were a Bell, A Bushel and A Peck, Guys and Dolls, and, of course, Luck Be A Lady.
At the preview performance I attended on Saturday, May 23, audience members could hardly wait to jump to their feet to give the cast a well-deserved standing ovation amidst shouts of Bravo.
(Pictured: Devon Michael Brown with members of the company. Photo: Ann Baggley.)
To be sure, if you are a fan of musical theatre (and even if you aren’t), you don’t want to miss this outstanding production.
As a rule, the Stratford Festival presents two major musical productions each season. Last season’s box office smash, Something Rotten, returns to the Festival stage for a command performance. Featuring many of the cast members of Guys and Dolls, it’s definitely a show you want to see if you missed it last year.
Reviewed by Richard Young, Publisher & Content Manager of The Beat Magazine 2025.
Richard's Blog 